The Right DFM Tools Will Reduce Product Costs & Development Time
The world of product development is changing. Globalization has offered new potentials for companies to grow their business, but also created increased pressure at the same time since global markets also create global competition. Shortening time to market is a goal almost every company is mentioning in their annual reports in one form or another.
Development Teams Under Increased Pressure to Reduce Time to Market
The prevailing theme of being first to market provides the best chance to win business leads to increased pressure on product development teams:
- Product lifecycles are becoming shorter, e.g. lifespan of consumer TV has reduced from 10 years to 6 months1
- Products become more complex and more functions need to be integrated, e.g. the VW Golf I in 1974 had one electrical engine control unit, today’s Golf VI has 50+2
- It has become common sense that the Design Engineer casts the biggest shadow on product cost. By only consuming 5% of the cost he has influence on up to 70% of the total cost with his decisions as the shadow diagram illustrates below:
What does this have to do with Design for Manufacturing (DFM)?
Before we answer this question, let’s take a step back and create a common understanding of what is meant by DFM. In the book Product Design for Manufacture and Assembly, DFM (design for manufacturing) is defined as design with the focus to ease production by manufacturing oriented designs of components.3
The main goal of this technique is to design streamlined products that allow reduced and optimized manufacturing cost which is in line with the message that designers influence the majority of product cost. Also it helps to avoid situations where engineering designs products without considering how they should be manufactured and sends designs to manufacturing and/or sourcing that they can hardly work with.
Achieving the Full Potential of DFM Requires the Right Tools
Design engineers often lack tools that could help them judge manufacturability, efficiency, and manufacturing cost of their designs in a consistent way. Without those tools, they either stay within areas of expertise where they feel confident to make the right decisions or they consult with process and manufacturing subject matter experts which is time consuming.
Although this cross-functional exchange between departments is beneficial, it often does nothing to reduce time to market and shorten development cycles.
To harvest the full potential of DFM in an effective way, tools that help the design engineer consistently evaluate manufacturability and cost of different design alternatives against each other in a timely manner need to be made available to designers.
Different software providers have engaged in this field and offer solutions for manufacturing and assembly cycle time and feasibility information as well as costs. One such solution is aPriori, a leading feature based product costing software.
Evaluate Manufacturability and Cost Simultaneously to Speed Up Product Development
From within aPriori design engineers can access their CAD design and input some basic information about the part or assembly like annual volume, location, material. aPriori then analyzes the CAD geometry for its cost drivers within a given manufacturing process group. Within this process group aPriori evaluates which routings are suitable to manufacture the part and what the cycle time and material utilization will be.
Another key output is the cost of the part. The entire process happens almost in real time and due to the minimized manual inputs it delivers consistent results allowing engineers to explore ideas that may not be common for them today.
The benefits of this computer aided costing are obvious:
- It reduces time to market by reducing the time needed to create effective designs and the amount of exchange between different groups.
- It delivers consistent results to everyone using it which avoids the same design being judged differently by different individuals.
- It creates important cost information that helps companies to manage product cost and launch products at or below target cost and secure margins early and fast in the design process.
One of the most recent development projects at aPriori to further support DFM capabilities in a more active way is the development of a DFM analysis feature which identifies sub-optimal areas of a design so the designer gets immediate feedback, as shown in the image below, when the design is not suitable for manufacturing.
DFM helps companies design products that are easier to manufacture which results in lower manufacturing cost since the design engineer has the most influence on product cost.
With the ambition to harvest the full potential of this technique, companies need to provide software tools that support their design engineers with manufacturing and cost information throughout product development.
In addition to supporting the DFM technique and providing cost feedback, those tools also help reduce time during the product development process since they deliver consistent real-time feedback to design engineers to support their decisions.
Hungry for more? Check out our white paper, What Will My Design Cost to Produce?
2. “Unter Innovationsdruck mit Kostenmanagement besser werden”, M. Preu, Head of Cost Management at VW AG, 2015
3. Product Design for Manufacture and Assembly, Third Edition (Manufacturing Engineering and Materials Processing), Geoffrey Boothroyd, Peter Dewhurst, Winston A. Knight, CRC Press 2010