Back to aPriori Blog Home

How to Use Fact-Based Negotiation to Get the Best Price on Existing Components

 — November 19, 2026
Watch Our Webinar to Explore aPriori’s Latest Releases
(opens in a new tab)
Listen to this Article 1×
00:00 00:00

Key Takeaways:

  • Use procurement and strategic sourcing to target high-spend parts, prioritizing negotiations when prices exceed your should cost estimate by 20% or more
  • Compare supplier quotes with your should cost model to identify inflated costs in overhead, labor rates, cycle times, and secondary processes
  • Review low estimates with suppliers to find hidden cost drivers, improve routing, or request an updated quote

The Full Article:

Fact-based negotiation is an effective cost-reduction strategy when you source existing components. In this post, I explain how to use digital manufacturing simulation to prepare for should cost negotiation. I also share real-world examples of manufacturers that saved significantly on current products.

What Do I Mean by Fact-Based Negotiations?

Digital manufacturing simulation must provide a complete cost breakdown for a part. This includes labor rates, overhead expenses, tooling investments, and material and manufacturing process costs. These insights help you understand the part’s cost structure and how its manufacturing cost is calculated.

That detailed cost information guides your supplier negotiations and helps you focus on the largest gaps between your data and theirs. This approach is much more effective than saying “your price is too high” or “I want a 10 percent reduction in costs.”

Identify Candidates for Immediate Negotiation

When you look for cost-reduction opportunities among existing components, start by narrowing your targets and setting the scope of what you will take to suppliers. You can’t possibly negotiate everything you buy.

I explain the methodology in my article, “How to Conduct a Spend Analysis.” In general, I recommend you target the items where you spend the most money, because those offer larger savings opportunities.

When you run a should cost analysis on the components you chose for renegotiation, I recommend you double-check the materials, volumes, and secondary processes, such as paint, polishing, and heat treatment.

Aim for the most accurate cost estimate possible before you negotiate. Your overall number doesn’t need to be exact, but it must be a very good estimate to support your negotiation.

Once you generate your should cost estimates, identify the parts where the price you pay exceeds the estimate by more than 20%, and start negotiating those components immediately.

Sometimes the difference between your estimate and the price you pay is large, and an estimate may come in at half the price or even one-fourth or one-fifth of it.

It’s tempting to dismiss those estimates by saying, “The estimate must be wrong because it can’t be that far off.” But a large gap between your estimate and the price can mean that your calculation leaves something out or that you don’t fully understand the production process.

It’s worth investigating, so I recommend you contact your supplier to find out where the difference comes from.

Case Study 1: Spend Analysis Finds $250K Annual Savings Opportunity

As an example, I worked with a truck manufacturer whose digital manufacturing simulation software estimated that a roof should cost about half of what the company was actually paying.

When we contacted the supplier, we had an open conversation and said, “We’ve been analyzing all our high-spend parts and generating cost estimates. We estimated the cost of this roof, but it isn’t nearly as high as what we’re paying. We want to understand where the cost goes. Can you help us with that?”

As it turns out, the specified painting process required the supplier to polish the roof. Because the roof was a concave part, a sander might deform it, so the supplier had to polish it by hand, which added significant cost.

In this case, the supplier was charging a fair price because the part should cost that much, but now the customer knew the reason.

The customer went back to the engineering team to reassess the paint spec, which was costing an extra $250,000 per year.

That’s the kind of information you can act on when you conduct fact-based negotiations with your suppliers. In other cases, you may find the supplier made a mistake, and you should pay half or one-fourth of what you were paying. I’ll share an example of that later.

Identify Standard Outliers

Next, identify standard outliers, which are parts where the price you pay differs by 25% to 40% from what your digital manufacturing solution estimates they should cost. The difference is significant enough to be an outlier, so I again recommend starting with a conversation with your supplier about where the cost comes from.

You may be missing a process, or the gap may have another valid reason, so the conversation starts with “What is the cost breakdown?”

If you can’t resolve the cost difference reasonably, investigate the details and begin the should cost negotiation process.

Get Detailed Cost Breakdowns for Outliers

Many companies ask for a detailed cost breakdown right from the start. If you haven’t, make that your first step. Ask the supplier to group the price by material, manufacturing, machining, tooling, fixtures, assembly, secondary processes, inspection, and transportation.

Compare the supplier’s numbers to the should cost estimate from your digital manufacturing simulation software. Suppliers often can’t itemize every category, but virtually all of them know their material, production, tooling, secondary processes, and transportation numbers. I know because I’ve been on the supply side. At a minimum, your software can give you the same breakdown.

Identify Excessive Premiums

At this point, you have a cost breakdown from the supplier and one from your software. Ask the supplier which secondary processes they perform in-house and which they outsource, so you can see how much extra you pay for work they can’t do themselves.

If the supplier sends the part out for paint or heat treatment, how much do they add to what they pay? If the premium is as high as 50%, you can negotiate it down to something more reasonable, like 20%.

The same goes for transportation. If the supplier pays to ship parts to and from a sub-supplier, you should cover that expense because it’s part of the cost, not a high markup. Accept a fair premium, not an excessive one.

Focus Your Cost-Savings Investigations

Next, compare the detailed cost breakdowns to find your biggest differences and focus your cost-savings investigations. Start with these questions:

  • Do material costs account for the biggest difference?
  • Is utilization lower than you expected?
  • Does the supplier use a different manufacturing process?
  • What are the setup costs, and does the supplier know them?
  • What batch sizes does the supplier run?
  • What are the supplier’s labor costs?

Then investigate the largest differences and assess the cost drivers behind them.

Examine the Manufacturing Process and Production Volume

Find out how the supplier makes the part, then compare that process to what your digital manufacturing simulation software recommends. If the two differ, ask why.

The supplier may have limited capabilities that worked when your volumes were low but no longer fit as your volumes grow. For example, you may have bought one thousand parts per year that the supplier made on a turret press. At 15k parts per year, stamping the component probably costs less. In that case, offer to buy the die or tooling, since the investment may pay off.

Sometimes you have to change suppliers. Your current supplier may lack the equipment to make the part with the most economical process.

Case Study 2: Routing Change Reduces Part Cost by 80%

I worked with a customer who had bought the same spacer for more than a decade at about $4.80 per part. The supplier cut the part from bar and machined it, the only way to meet the original tolerances. aPriori’s Manufacturing Insights showed that a laser process should make the part and estimated its cost at about $0.85.

The customer asked the supplier for a requote and sent the part to other suppliers for quotes. One new quote came in at about $0.80 per part using a laser process.

The estimate was less than one-fifth of the price the customer had paid. The customer could’ve dismissed the gap with “That can’t be right” and moved on. Instead, they investigated why the estimate and the historical price differed so much, and they saved a significant amount on that one part.

Explore Material Cost Differences

Your biggest differences may come from material cost, which has several possible causes.

Your supplier may pay much more for raw material than you expected. If you have more buying power than a smaller supplier, offer to purchase the material and ship it directly to their factory.

Low utilization can also increase material cost. In that case, ask whether the supplier sells the scrap and whether you receive credit for it. Some suppliers give credit, and others don’t. Some say they already include it in the price by discounting the cost per pound up front, since they know what the scrap will bring. Have the conversation either way.

Scrutinize Setup Costs

Many buyers overlook setup costs, but they can reveal savings when you negotiate with suppliers. If your digital manufacturing simulation software shows that setup makes a significant share of part’s total cost, say 15% or 20%, ask your supplier what batch size they run, since it may not match your order quality.

Subscribe to the aPriori Blog!

Automate Cost Intelligence to Launch Faster and Protect Margin

Connect aPriori to your PLM so engineers and procurement can see manufacturing costs as they design. Catch cost problems early, launch sooner, and protect margin.
Access The Webinar